|
Giving Criticism
1. Be objective. Try to judge the work according to the attempted style rather than judging it according to your own tastes. 2. Remember your initial reactions, but wait until you can effectively explain yourself. 3. Avoid suggesting changes unless prompted. 4. Be specific. It is always hard to take criticism, especially when you don't understand it. 5. Do not make criticisms unless it is an appropriate place and time. 6. Avoid heated arguments or stressful situations. If tempers begin to rise during a critique, stop. 7. Try to validate your criticism with specific examples and references. Receiving Criticism 1. Criticism can be a great tool towards evolving and improving your work. 2. Attempt to display your work in a manner as close to how it will eventually be presented. 3. Make sure you have a very firm idea of what you had intended before accepting criticism on it. Otherwise, the criticism could end up having adverse affects upon your work. 4. Take notes. This helps signify to that you take their ideas seriously, and in turn makes them work harder to give a good critique. Further, you have notes to refer to should you intend to act upon the suggestion. 5.If you believe that the person is offering valuable insight, but does not fully understand your intentions, take the time to explain it. 6.The thoughts and critiques of the intended audience of your work should weigh highly on any changes made. 7.Do not get angry or irritated. If a person offends you, end the conversation. |